Supreme Court Lays Down the Law on Commercial Property Service Charges

Many commercial leases appear to confer on landlords a wide and unilateral power to calculate and demand payment of service charges. An important Supreme Court ruling, however, indicates that they may not enjoy quite such a whip hand in future. Sharon Tait looks at the case.

A substantial commercial tenant was served with certified service charge demands totalling over £400,000. In refusing to pay, it asserted that they were excessive and included items and expenses that were not properly due under the terms of its leases. The landlord, however, pointed to a clause in the leases which stated that the certified bills were ‘conclusive’ subject only to the defences that there had been a manifest error, a mathematical error or fraud.

The tenant argued that the true meaning of the certification clause was that the bills were conclusive as to the amount of costs incurred by the landlord, but not as to the tenant’s liability for service charges. The Court of Appeal, however, preferred the landlord’s more natural interpretation of the clause and it was awarded summary judgment in the full amount of the disputed service charges.

By a majority, the Supreme Court dismissed the tenant’s appeal against that ruling. Crucially, however, it found that the tenant was not precluded from pursuing a counterclaim in relation to its underlying liability for the disputed service charges.

The Court found neither side’s interpretation of the certification clause satisfactory. The landlord’s argument that the certified bills were, subject to the listed defences, conclusive as to the extent of the tenant’s liability fitted well with the wording of the clause. However, that reading was inconsistent with other provisions of the leases which, amongst other things, conferred a right on the tenant to inspect receipts, invoices and other documents on which the demands were based.

It would also, the Court noted, be surprising if the landlord were unilaterally entitled to conclusively resolve issues in relation to liability for service charges without the tenant having any opportunity to make representations. That would amount to a ‘pay now, argue never’ regime. On the other hand, the tenant’s interpretation of the certification clause conflicted with its natural and ordinary meaning.

The Court found that an alternative interpretation of the clause was possible which would avoid such difficulties. It accepted that the certified bills were conclusive and that the tenant was required to pay them, subject to the permitted defences. That reading of the certification clause would enable the landlord to recover service charges without protracted delay or dispute, thus protecting its cashflow.

However, the Court went on to find that, on a true reading of the certification clause, the tenant was not precluded from later disputing liability for any service charge payments made. Such an interpretation gave full effect to the tenant’s inspection rights and entitled it to pursue arguable claims in respect of service charge liability. The Court noted that its reading of the certification clause gave rise to the type of ‘pay now, argue later’ regime that is commonly found in commercial contracts.

We Asked Associate Solicitor Sharon Tait For Her Expert Insight – 

‘It is important to ensure that your lease is correctly drafted in the first place, this is something that we can help you with.  If you are a tenant it may a false economy to assume that your landlord must be drafting the lease correctly and that you can accept the draft that they present without challenge, it is always better to seek independent legal advice.

If you are a landlord you are better to have your tenant’s lease properly drafted at the outset as this is likely to save you on legal and court costs if the terms are disputed further down the line, this is something we can help you with.’

We've Got Your Back

If you need assistance or advice in regard to any aspect of this issue, we can help

Call Sharon on 01254 92 65 18, email info@carterssolicitors.co.uk or complete our online enquiry form and one of our experts will contact you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *